A new study finds federal programs that teach "abstinence only" to reduce teen pregnancy don't work. An evaluation by Mathematica Policy Research (funded by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services), concludes young people are no more likely to delay sexual activity after participating in those programs. Minnesota teen advocate Brigid Riley with the Minnesota Organization for Adolescent Pregnancy, Prevention and Parenting says what has proven successful is a varied approach.
"Programs that emphasize abstinence, but also share information about condoms and contraceptives, have a much stronger effect on keeping young people pregnancy free and HIV free."
The report shows federal funding for abstinence programs has grown over the past decade to $176 million a year. Riley argues that investing so much in a single, unproven approach is a risky strategy. She adds that everyone wants to reduce teen pregnancy, but it's about the approach.
"Unfortunately, these programs don't go far enough, in that they don't give accurate information about contraception, they don't tell young people about any of those kinds of choices or where health clinics are, or anything else. It's a main focus on remaining abstinent. That's all these programs are doing."
"Abstinence only" supporters say that more information could encourage more sexual activity. Riley hopes the study encourages policymakers to put taxpayer dollars into sex education programs that both advocate abstinence and offer information about contraception because that works best. She believes that federal teen pregnancy prevention efforts need to have a broader perspective to reach more teens.
"These programs can actually include a lot more information about relationships, about violence in relationships, about a whole broad array of things."
She notes some Minnesota's programs to reduce teen pregnancy promote better parent-child communications and provide after-school activities, which work to lower teen pregnancy rates.
The report is at www.mathematica-mpr.com.
get more stories like this via email
LANSING, Mich. -- The voices of expectant and parenting youths are being amplified by the first-ever Michigan Young Parent Advisory Council.
Diamond Weakley is among the 13 teens on the council, which is based in Saginaw. She said the group is reducing the stigma and isolation she's experienced as a young parent.
"A lot of families don't support youths having children before graduating. So it makes us feel better about becoming young parents and keeping our kids instead of listening to everybody about how hard parenting may be," Weakley said.
Council Facilitator Robert Clark, a case manager at Saginaw Intermediate School District, said one of their first projects was to raise awareness about the lack of spaces where parents can change a baby's diaper in women's and men's public restrooms.
"So their next objective is to let these companies know why it's important to have a baby changing station in their restaurant or facility," Clark said.
The program is supported by the Michigan Organization on Adolescent Sexual Health through funding from the National Institute for Reproductive Health. Council members are compensated for their time and efforts, including child care during meetings.
Clark said it's important to support and empower young parents as they work toward their goals, and to ensure they feel respected.
"And let them know it's OK to ask for help and they are heard when they do need anything," he said. "Because they are young parents, they feel like a lot of older adults talk down at them instead of talking with them on their level."
Teen mothers and fathers are at higher risk of dropping out of school and living in poverty, and have higher incidences of repeat births. Weakley agreed being a young parent is hard, but said her daughter is worth it.
"When I look at her and I see her smile, it just makes me want to live better," Weakley said. "Honestly, without my daughter, I don't think I would have graduated high school. I try to do everything that I want to see her do in her future so that she can say, 'Well, my mom did it, so I can do it.'"
Research shows when young parents are supported, they are better able to finish high school, pursue higher-level education and find employment.
get more stories like this via email
WHITESBURG, Ky. — Access to sex education is on the decline in rural areas, but one eastern Kentucky native aims to fill the knowledge gap with a traveling free sex education workshop called Sexy Sex Ed.
According to the Guttmacher Institute, in 2006, 71% of rural women were taught about birth control as an option to prevent pregnancy. That number shrunk to 48% by 2013. Tanya Turner, creator of the Sexy Sex Ed workshop said growing up in Bell County, she didn't receive any kind of instruction on sex or her own anatomy.
"I hope I'm not the only person teaching progressive, body-positive sex education in rural Appalachia, but all the stats show sex education in rural places is in on a huge decline,” Turner said.
What started out as a small project nearly a decade ago has grown into a year-round traveling workshop that has reached hundreds of youths across five Appalachian states. Recent grant funding will allow Turner to expand her traveling workshop series.
Turner said her workshops weave in elements of theater, visual art, and writing to explore safety, anatomy, and consent.
"There are a lot of myths that I have to do a lot of myth busting, around virginity and birth control, consent - a lot of consent issues I think come up,” she said.
She said many teens are desperate for information, and pointed out many feel they can't ask their parents or other trusted adults questions about sexuality.
"'Cause they're certainly not getting it in their public school systems and in their homes, and what they are having access to in large part is very fear-based, very shame-based and not helpful, and honestly pretty traumatizing - certainly can be, especially for queer folks and people who are already marginalized,” Turner said.
Research has shown that when sex education includes information about contraception, teens are less likely to become pregnant compared to those who receive abstinence-only or no sex education. According to federal data, Kentucky ranks among the top five states in the country for teens births.
get more stories like this via email
NASHVILLE, Tenn. – Tennesseans can now get a clearer picture of teen pregnancies in the state.
The State Comptroller's office has released an interactive map that illustrates which counties have high teen birthrates.
John Dunn, a spokesman for the Tennessee Comptroller of the Treasury, explains the map shows the percentages of teen pregnancies per 1,000 girls ages 15 to 17.
"What our map shows is that there are 37 Tennessee counties, which is more than one-third of the counties in the state of Tennessee, that have a teen pregnancy rate which exceeds 19.5, and that means that those counties have to teach a Family Life Education Program in their high schools," he explains.
In Tennessee, counties with elevated teen pregnancy rates are required by law to offer Family Life Education in public schools.
According to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, since 1991, Tennessee's overall pregnancy rate has dropped by at least 45 percent.
A recent report by the Offices of Research and Education Accountability said Tennessee school districts lack guidance on what they should be teaching young people about preventing pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases.
State law says any sex education course must include presentations that encourage abstinence.
Dunn says the map is one way lawmakers can identify the steps being taken in their districts.
"The primary reason we put this information together is to provide lawmakers with information about their districts, so that they know whether or not education requirements like the Family Life Education program are being taught in their schools," he states.
According to the Tennessee Commission on Children and Youth, the number of teen pregnancies among 15-to-17-year-olds is on the decrease. Last year, pregnancies in that age group totaled more than 1,900, but five years ago, there were more than 3,000.
get more stories like this via email
Contact
