Court Asked to Put the Brakes on Oil Shale Fast-Track
Friday, January 16, 2009
Several environmental groups have filed suit against the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) to challenge a plan that clears the way for oil shale development in Colorado, Wyoming and Utah. While many promote oil shale as a non-foreign answer to the nation's oil needs, the lawsuit references BLM research documenting the lack of cost-effective and environmentally-sound technology to mine the oil shale.
Craig Thompson, a former oil shale worker and professor of engineering and environmental science at Western Wyoming Community College, says producing oil shale requires large amounts of energy and water. He adds, it causes widespread water pollution, which can reach neighboring states.
"I don't think it's a wise thing to do to jump into this right now. Every time we've tried it, it's been a failure economically and environmentally."
Thompson claims the project he worked on caused severe groundwater contamination and still is being cleaned up today, 30 years later. Oil shale seems like a good idea, in concept, agrees Thompson, because of the sheer size of the available reserve, but he says it's not crude oil. Thompson calls it a low-quality, oil-like substance that has to be used in much greater quantities than oil to generate the same quantity of energy. He claims that municipal garbage, and even prunes, have more energy content than the oil shale product.
"Oil shale, overall, doesn't yield a lot of heat. It's a filthy and poor excuse for a fuel."
Shell Oil is experimenting with new technology, but the company has not found it to be cost-effective, according to Thompson.
The National Wildlife Federation, Sierra Club, and The Wilderness Society are joining the lawsuit, alleging federal regulations approved for oil shale production don't protect water, communities, or the environment. The lawsuit was filed in U.S. District Court in Colorado.
get more stories like this via email
COLUMBUS, Ohio -- New congressional and legislative maps will soon start to take shape in Ohio. The Ohio Redistricting Commission convenes for the …
DENVER -- Today marks the day Black women in the U.S. will finally earn as much as a white, non-Hispanic man was paid in 2020. Ashley Panelli…
WARREN, Pa. -- A temporary animal-feeding ban is being proposed for the Allegheny National Forest after a captive deer tested positive for chronic …
LOS ANGELES -- Hunger-fighting advocacy groups are speaking out in California, drawing attention to the continuing problem of food insecurity…
SACRAMENTO, Calif. -- Parents are gearing up for their children to return to the classroom for the first time in over a year, and public health …
LITCHFIELD, N.H. -- A 63-acre parcel of land along the Merrimack River is becoming part of the New Hampshire Agrarian Commons. The property, known as …
RICHMOND, Va. - Virginia's General Assembly Special Session begins today to budget more than $4 billion in federal COVID relief funds, and advocates …
ROSLINDALE, Mass. - A new report finds Massachusetts residents would rather repair electronic devices than send them to landfills, but manufacturers …