NEW YORK - With poverty and the problems that go with it on the rise, more than 90 grantmaking foundations are banding together to help underserved communities in New York and the nation. They began signing on to Philanthropy's Promise this summer, and as of today they have pledged $1.5 billion to help fight poverty and address social problems.
Megan Bell, executive director of the Wilson Foundation, Rochester, says the effort is well timed, given the latest census numbers showing that one in five New Yorkers is stuck in poverty.
"We can't take over the burden of the government, but if all these foundations can band together and provide their resources in a more effective way, we hope to provide a bigger impact and take over some of the hardship caused by some of these government cuts."
Signatories of Philanthropy's Promise intend to use two high-impact strategies in their philanthropy for the next three years: dedicate at least 50 percent of their giving for the benefit of at least one underserved community, and dedicate 25 percent toward supporting policy and civic engagement.
The Wilson Foundation is among the organizations that has pledged to focus on social problems. The foundation has invested $900,000 in the fight against homelessness in Rochester, creating solutions that could work nationally.
Anika Rahman, president and CEO of the Ms. Foundation for Women, says her group also signed up for the Promise, pledging $3.5 million to groups that help women. She says part of that funding will help domestic workers, to ensure that the legislative gains they won in Albany are carried out.
"In November 2010, Domestic Workers United passed the New York State Domestic Workers Bill of Rights, which provides basic labor protections like overtime pay to more than 200,000 individuals."
Ms. Foundation for Women is also concerned that the recovery from the Great Recession has been slower for women, Rahman adds. Men have regained about 15 percent of the jobs they lost, while women have regained only 13 percent, she explains.
Bell points out that the growing gap between rich and poor is making it tough for mid-sized cities like Rochester to cope with problems like homelessness.
"There is such a concentration of wealth that the people who just can't quite reach those levels are having a hard time finding affordable rent, because the cost of living is so high."
Philanthropy's Promise (www.philanthropyspromise.org) is encouraging more foundations to sign on. It is a project of the National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy (NCRP).
Further information is available at www.mcjcwilsonfoundation.org and www.ms.foundation.org.
get more stories like this via email
A new report argued many charitable foundations need to examine the origin of their wealth and repair harms done.
The National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy used publicly available information to examine how historic business fortunes behind some foundations were made. Drawing on historic examples of businesses profiting from systemic racism and discrimination, the report titled "Cracks in the Foundation" stressed the need for philanthropic organizations to do their own research, connect with Black communities, and move charity dollars toward repairs.
Claire Dunning, assistant professor of Public Policy at the University of Maryland, served on the report's advisory committee and said foundations can seek partnerships including local history centers to help with the process.
"This doesn't have to be a private, or sort of closed-off process," Dunning contended. "It can be one rooted in transparency and inviting people in. And again, that can be uncomfortable. But I would argue that's not an excuse to not begin this important work."
The report presented case studies tracking the economic history of eight foundations in the Washington, D.C., area. The study's authors said they seek to make difficult conversations easier and are presenting the case studies as educational guides for an accountability and healing journey.
In looking at historic harms, the report focused on four sectors: media including anti-Black rhetoric; housing including discrimination, segregation and displacement; employment including stolen labor; and health care including mental and physical harm and neglect. The report assessed harm using both quantitative and qualitative methods. Dunning stressed in looking to the historical record to find evidence of past harm, researchers must take a broad view.
"We need to think about how newspaper accounts or advertisements for a particular neighborhood that talk about restrictive covenants. That's a form of evidence," Dunning pointed out. "We can think about oral histories of people who are displaced from certain neighborhoods or who were denied equal wages in an employment situation, that's a form of evidence."
The Federal government requires private foundations to use their assets to benefit society. Each year they must distribute at least 5% of the market value of their endowment to charitable purposes.
get more stories like this via email
A new report said philanthropic organizations need to reexamine the source of their wealth, which it asserted often came from systemic racism and discrimination, and stressed the need to repair the harm done to Black communities.
Called "Cracks in the Foundation," the report from the National Committee on Responsive Philanthropy examines at the histories of eight grantmakers.
Katherine Ponce, research manager of special projects for the committee, explained how the report was developed.
"There's four categories of harm we focus on," Ponce pointed out. "It's anti-Black media and rhetoric, housing discrimination and segregation, unemployment and hidden opportunity, and then health care, both mental and physical."
The report urged grantmakers to reckon with their past, connect with harmed communities, work to repair the damage, make sure any harm doesn't continue and advocate for funding for reparations. While the report focuses on the Washington, D.C., area, it mentions California's Task Force to Study and Develop Reparation Proposals for African Americans as an encouraging development.
Hanh Le, co-CEO of if: A Foundation for Radical Possibility, which commissioned the report and is one of the institutions examined, said her organization once believed the money to endow the foundation came from a health association jointly created by Black and Jewish workers when in fact, the agency initially excluded Black workers.
"Every foundation has an origin story that we believe ties the wealth that generated the endowment for those foundations to racialized capitalism, to structural racism," Le contended. "We all have an obligation to know that truth, to reckon with the truth and to repair the harm."
Debra Watkins, founder and executive director of San Jose-based ABEN, which stands for A Black Education Network, said to play a role in repair, grantmakers should invest in Black-led organizations, which still only get a fraction of the billions given annually.
"Foundations that have amassed their wealth as a result of harm done to Black people over decades, now have an obligation to fund Black-led work," Watkins urged. "And also to ameliorate conditions under which Black people still live."
Disclosure: The National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy contributes to our fund for reporting on Health Issues, Immigrant Issues, Reproductive Health, and Women's Issues. If you would like to help support news in the public interest,
click here.
get more stories like this via email
On Giving Tuesday tomorrow, donating money isn't the only way to support the groups and causes you care about.
The global Giving Tuesday movement promotes "radical generosity," defined as "the concept that the suffering of others should be as intolerable to us as our own suffering."
Millions of people in the U.S. pledged a total of over $3 billion on Giving Tuesday last year - a 15% increase over 2021.
Philanthropy Ohio President and CEO Deborah Aubert Thomas said by occurring during the holiday season, Giving Tuesday lends itself to a particular type of giving.
"I think the timing of Giving Tuesday really gives the opportunity to focus on the things that we are all giving thanks for on Thanksgiving," said Thomas, "things that we know not everyone in our communities have access to - food and housing and just basic human securities."
Thomas said in 2020 - the most recent year for which IRS data is available - nearly 4,000 Ohio foundations donated $1.94 billion.
She explained that because fewer people itemize on their tax returns since the 2017 tax changes, it's hard to assess individual giving.
But prior to tax law changes, total giving by individual Ohioans was triple that of foundation giving. And the majority was by households with annual incomes of between $50,000 and $200,000.
She said children can learn about philanthrophy by sharing their "time, talent and treasures" at a young age.
"One of the best ways to do that is through community service and volunteering," said Thomas. "And through that learning about what the issues are in their communities, so that they can connect to what is sort of their passion and where they see they would like to make a difference, both with their time as well as through their giving."
Pointing out that philanthropy is defined as love of humankind and love of mankind, Thomas said it can start in your own neighborhood.
"Every community and even every neighborhood has unique needs," said Thomas. "And I think for folks to get off of their screens and learn about their neighbors and where there's need. I think philanthropy is - it's a state of mind as much as it is an activity."
The Giving Tuesday website reports that more than three-fourths of acts of generosity are non-monetary.
This story was produced in association with Media in the Public Interest and funded in part by the George Gund Foundation.
get more stories like this via email