WI Attorney: $25 Million Jury Award Is Reasonable
Wednesday, October 22, 2014
MADISON, Wis. - The president of the Wisconsin Association for Justice says a recent verdict demonstrates a need for change in the state's malpractice laws.
A Milwaukee woman, Ascaris Mayo, who lost all four limbs because of medical malpractice, recently won a more than $25 million jury verdict, in which the judge ruled that the state's $750,000 cap on malpractice awards was unconstitutional in her case.
Attorney Chris Stombaugh at WAJ said the award is huge - but so were Mayo's injuries.
"It's hard to imagine what it would be like as a human being not having legs or arms, and the amount of quality-of-life disturbance that we're talking about here is just probably unimaginable," he said, "and so this number, I think, appropriately reflects what happened to her as a human being."
Mayo, a housewife and mother of four, lost all her limbs because a blood infection went undiagnosed, resulting in septic shock. Judge Jeffery Conen said the award was proportionate with her injuries, and Stombaugh concurred.
"Her ability to lead any kind of a normal life is destroyed. There's no changing that," he said. "But I think she's a testament to an individual's character and strength that she continues on, but that doesn't mean we should undervalue what has been lost in the process."
Stombaugh said the jury's verdict and the judge's ruling indicates there may be change in the wind regarding the state's malpractice award limits. He called the decision "good news" for every Wisconsinite.
"There's a great number of people in this state who are affected," he said, "actually our most vulnerable - the retired, our children, homemakers for example who can't prove that they have an income, but they make tremendous contributions to our lives, who can't afford to bring those cases because the lawyers can't afford to bring them for them."
Stombaugh said the state laws regarding medical malpractice stack the deck against people such as Mayo.
Supporters of the $750,000 cap say it keeps malpractice insurance costs down, but Stombaugh said that's not really an issue in Wisconsin.
Conen wrote that payment of the entire $25 million award would have little impact on the state's $1.15 billion fund that pays medical malpractice claims.
get more stories like this via email
SALT LAKE CITY -- In the push toward carbon-free energy production, some cities in Utah and nearby states are considering a new type of nuclear …
Health and Wellness
TAMPA, Fla. -- Move United's USA Wheelchair Football League is expanding from four cities to nine, including Tampa, to give athletes with …
CRAIG, Colo. -- What would it look like if one in four households in the country was solar-powered? A new report from the "30 Million Solar Homes" …
Health and Wellness
DES MOINES, Iowa -- People across the Midwest, including Iowans, have dealt with a series of heat waves this summer. Health experts say hotter …
NEW YORK -- Over 10,000 New York and New Jersey front-line airport workers will get health insurance as part of new contract negotiations that come at…
INDIANAPOLIS -- Voting-rights advocates applaud this week's federal appeals-court decision to prevent Indiana from purging some voters from the rolls …
BOSTON -- A new survey finds widespread public support up and down the East Coast for protecting right whales from getting tangled up in fishing gear…
CARSON CITY, Nev. - A bill just introduced in the U.S, Senate would help thousands of species stay off the Endangered Species List - including …