WI Trial Lawyer: Proposed Constitutional Amendment a Bad Idea
Monday, February 9, 2015
MILWAUKEE – A proposed constitutional amendment would end Wisconsin's 126-year tradition of having the court's justice with the longest tenure serve as chief justice.
The amendment would have the court's seven members elect their own leader every two years.
Milwaukee trial attorney Ann Jacobs is strongly opposed to the amendment, which is likely to be on the April 7 ballot.
"This law advocates taking away from citizens their right to elect their chief justice, which is what they did when they re-elected Justice Abrahamson,” she stresses. “It's unfortunate and I think goes counter to our very populist view here in Wisconsin."
Although supporters of the amendment deny it, others are calling the amendment effort a coordinated attack on Chief Justice Shirley Abrahamson, who has served as chief justice for the past 18 years.
Supporters say the change would encourage more collegiality among the justices.
Many observers note the court has been mired in partisan bickering for the past several years, between what's seen as the conservative and liberal members of the court.
Jacobs maintains the amendment would make the situation worse.
"Rather than mitigating the political infighting within the court, by creating a popularity contest on this important issue every two years what we're doing is heightening the political fracturing of our supreme court," she states.
Proponents of the amendment disagree, saying the change will promote greater collegiality and will encourage the justices to get along with each other.
Abrahamson is considered part of the liberal faction on the court, but is known nationally as an impartial jurist with a sharp mind and as a hard-working justice.
Jacobs says she has greater concerns than the personality issues surfacing in discussions of the proposed amendment.
"There is a question raised as to whether or not this is going to impact checks and balances between the court and the legislature, in part because it affects a sitting justice in the midst of her term," she explains.
Jacobs says if supporters of the amendment were not making this a personal attack on Abrahamson, they would have proposed that the new law take effect after the conclusion of Abrahamson's term.
get more stories like this via email
BOISE, Idaho -- Wildfires are affecting air quality across the West, bringing hidden dangers in smoke that can harm people's health. The Boise-based …
DENVER -- The days of exponentially high increases in health-insurance costs may finally be in the rearview mirror. The Colorado Division of …
DES MOINES, Iowa -- Cultural institutions in the U.S. are facing scrutiny to be more accessible and inclusive. The organization in charge of Iowa's …
BELLINGHAM, Wash. -- Last month's deadly heat wave in the Northwest underscored the need to reduce carbon emissions, but advocates want to ensure low-…
MINOT, N.D. -- Many arguments are being floated about legislation before Congress that would bring big changes to U.S. labor laws. The bill has its …
Health and Wellness
JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. -- Health-care advocates called on Missouri lawmakers to allocate funds for Medicaid expansion right away, after the state …
AUGUSTA, Maine -- School meals in Maine will be free for all students again this year and into the future, but parents are being urged to fill out …
CHARLESTON, W.Va. -- A report outlines how federal efforts to bring solar energy to one in four American households could bring clean energy to …