IN Bill Guaranteeing Right to 'Peaceful Death' Stalls
Tuesday, March 8, 2022
A bill permitting medical aid in dying for terminally ill patients has failed to advance in the Indiana General Assembly. The measure would have guaranteed what its proponents consider the right to a peaceful death.
Bev Hmurovic, president of Compassion & Choices Indiana, said it is the sixth time the bill has been introduced, only to expire in a legislative committee without a hearing, but she said the bill's supporters are not giving up any time soon.
"We don't have any reason, even in the next year or two, to think that we'll get it to move further," Hmurovic acknowledged. "We'd just really like for it to get a hearing, so that we could find out what are the other viewpoints on the issue."
Opponents of the practice argued it can be abused and people could be coerced into it. Hmurovic countered the bill has numerous safeguards in place to ensure it does not happen. Among other things, patients seeking medical aid in dying must have a six-month terminal diagnosis, be a legal adult, be judged competent by a physician and self-administer the medication.
A new poll commissioned by Compassion & Choices found nearly 70% of voters support medical aid in dying for the terminally ill.
Rep. Matt Pierce, D-Bloomington, the bill's sponsor, said getting it through the Republican-controlled Public Health Committee has been an uphill battle.
"The chair of the committee that the bill gets assigned to really has sole discretion as to whether or not to hear a bill, so you've got to get them to put it on their agenda," Pierce explained. "And that's the starting point, and often the hardest part of the entire process."
Jim Lee, CEO of Susquehanna Polling and Research, which conducted the survey, said support for the practice is consistent across political and religious affiliations. Among Republican respondents, 68% said they supported medical aid in dying, as did 70% of Democrats.
"The fact that we have strong consensus on this type of medical issue, I think, speaks volumes," Lee emphasized.
Kim Callinan, CEO of Compassion & Choices, noted the poll found people are more likely to vote for candidates who back medical aid-in-dying bills.
"What it tells a candidate is that they have nothing to lose and everything to gain being a champion for medical aid in dying," Callinan contended.
Ten states and Washington, D.C. have all approved measures guaranteeing medical aid in dying.
get more stories like this via email
The number of people with some higher education but no degree or other credential to show for it has increased in recent years, according to a new …
Starting this month, chemical companies will resume being taxed for cleanup of areas with a lot of leftover toxic waste, also known as Superfund …
Today is the deadline for Missouri residents to make sure they are registered to vote if they want to cast a ballot in the August primary. Eligible …
As states ban abortion with the overturning of Roe v. Wade, women's advocates in New York and beyond are raising awareness of the outsized impact …
The fate of more than 600,000 so-called "dreamers" hangs in the balance as opening statements are heard today in a case that could make or break the D…
A four-year project to map big-game routes throughout the West will end without additional funds from Congress - at least for now. Since 2018…
Groups working to curb climate change said a Supreme Court ruling limiting the ability of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to control carbon …
Government labels on meat products that say "humane" or "raised in a stress-free environment" are meaningless, according to some animal-rights groups…