PA Gerrymandering Ruling Called Major Victory
Wednesday, January 24, 2018
HARRISBURG, Pa. – Election law advocates say the state Supreme Court's ruling declaring Pennsylvania's congressional map unconstitutional was the first of its kind in the nation.
On Monday, the court said the map created by Republicans in 2011 was drawn to discriminate against Democrats.
With it, the GOP has consistently held 13 of the state's 18 congressional districts despite the fact that voters are pretty evenly divided between the parties.
According to Michael Li, senior redistricting counsel with the Brennan Center for Justice at the New York University School of Law, this is the first time a court has relied on general provisions of a state constitution to strike down gerrymandered district lines. And that, he says, is huge.
"It means that there is now a potential second front in the war against partisan gerrymandering that there wasn't before that doesn't depend on what the U.S. Supreme Court does," he explains.
The General Assembly has until Feb. 9 to submit a new district plan to Gov. Tom Wolf.
Republicans in the state Senate say they will request a stay from the U.S. Supreme Court.
But Li maintains the federal high court would have little if any reason to intervene.
"This is a decision that was solely based on the Pennsylvania Constitution and provisions that actually predate the U.S. Constitution, and so it's really hard to see what basis they would have for appealing to the U.S. Supreme Court," he points out.
Supporters of redistricting note that a more impartial map also would put more Republicans in Democratic districts, making elections more competitive overall.
Li explains that many state constitutions have broader protections for electoral rights than the U.S. Constitution, so the ruling in the Pennsylvania court could serve as a model for other states.
"State courts oftentimes look to each other for guidance on how to handle issues where they have similar provisions, so the Pennsylvania decision could be really persuasive and helpful to other courts," he states.
The court has ordered that a new district plan be in place by Feb. 19, in time for primary elections coming up in May.
get more stories like this via email
One of North Carolina's oldest Historically Black Colleges and Universities is finding new ways to help students stay enrolled and graduate. Recent …
A new survey finds 8 in 10 Kentucky parents say afterschool programs could help their child combat social and mental-health struggles by reducing unpr…
A technology that once existed only in science fiction soon could emerge as a viable solution to climate change. The city of Flagstaff has added …
A new report found Texas likely undercounted the number of people who actually live in the state when gathering information for the 2020 census…
Minnesota has more than 10,000 brownfield sites, which are abandoned or idled properties in need of contamination removal. State officials will soon …
By age 35, workers with a bachelor's degree or higher are about twice as likely as workers with just a high school diploma to have a good job - one …
The mayor of Huntington, where more than 200 homes were recently damaged by severe flooding, said now is the state's "one chance" to prevent other …
Alzheimer's disease is one of the leading causes of death in North Dakota, prompting state officials to launch an online dashboard, where the public …