Public Water Fight: DEP Rules Now Before WV Legislature
Monday, January 21, 2019
CHARLESTON, W.Va. -- A normally boring rule-making process is turning into a water fight for lawmakers. At the request of the West Virginia Manufacturers Association, the state Department of Environmental Protection shelved three years of work updating nearly 100 water-quality standards on potentially toxic pollutants.
The question now comes before the Republican-controlled legislature. Public-health activist Maya Nye, pointed out the shelved updates are already a compromise. She said they don't cover important contaminants like C-8 or MCHM, known to have been in drinking water in the state.
"Let's just be clear that what is on the table is not what is most protective for the public health, period,” Nye said. “There are already a number of chemicals that aren't even identified. We know the human health effects, or we may not even know what the human health effects are."
The Manufacturers Association argues that the rules need to be more West Virginia-specific. The state Senate Energy, Industry, and Mining Committee may take the issue up as soon as Tuesday.
The Department of Environmental Protection gathered hundreds of pages of public comments and responses on the proposals before announcing it had agreed to withdraw the whole package. That was in November, during a legislative interim committee meeting. At that meeting, Manufacturers Association President Rebecca McPhail said the DEP rules needed more study.
"I guess, simply put, the changes that have been proposed to these human-health parameters without further analysis could create some uncertainty for industry and unnecessary burden, without scientifically demonstrating health benefits,” McPhail said.
The association has said West Virginians might differ from residents of other states in ways that could change the impact of water pollution, including average weight and typical consumption of water and freshwater fish. But according to DEP public statements, those were considered when the agency was writing the rules proposal.
More information is available at WVRivers.org.
get more stories like this via email
DENVER - On Wednesday, leaders from Colorado's 13 community colleges joined a national effort to help more of the state's adults get credentials and …
LAS VEGAS, Nev. -- Today, a virtual summit hosted by the Las Vegas Mayor's Faith Initiative looks at the crisis of missing and murdered Indigenous …
HOUSTON -- Many U.S. communities with bustling downtowns were better prepared to weather economic fallout from the pandemic, thanks to a decades-old …
MILWAUKEE, Wis. -- A Wisconsin group that advocates for working families is launching a new campaign, which connects federal policy to the …
SEATTLE - Constructive conversations online can seem few and far between. Research from the University of Washington explores how the design of …
Health and Wellness
WATERLOO, Iowa -- Advocates for Iowans with disabilities are sounding the alarm over what they describe as a caregiver crisis, pleading with …
BOISE, Idaho - Millions of members around the world, including some Idahoans, are observing International Credit Union Day today. This year marks 73…
INDIANAPOLIS -- As finding a career becomes more difficult for young people, a new report said the U.S. needs a more comprehensive approach to …