Report: NC’s ‘Raise the Age’ Law Led to Fewer Youths Charged as Adults
Monday, July 12, 2021
RALEIGH, N.C. -- In 2019, North Carolina stopped charging most 16- and 17-year-olds as adults, and a new report looks at the law's effects on the state's juvenile-justice system.
The state reported there was only a 38% increase in the number of youths referred to juvenile detention, about half of what was predicted, after raising the age a person can be charged as an adult to 18.
Tarrah Callahan, executive director of Raleigh-based Conservatives for Criminal Justice Reform, pointed to the numerous societal benefits of not charging kids as adults.
"Enabling this population to start out their lives as 18-year-olds without an adult criminal record hanging around their necks, to the fact that the majority of the kids in this system are coming in with a mental-health diagnosis and really ought to be treated accordingly," Callahan outlined.
Because the first full year of Raising the Age in North Carolina happened during the COVID-19 pandemic, the report found the number of juvenile court cases dipped dramatically and reduced the state's overall youth detention population.
Callahan pointed out both sides of the political aisle tout public safety as a priority, but haven't digested the volume of data on the efficacy of juvenile-detention policies.
"When we can show that tough-on-crime, 'lock em' up and throw away the key' policies, particularly for children, are not effective, then it really suggests that we need to contemplate a much more holistic approach," Callahan urged.
Marcy Mistrett, senior fellow at The Sentencing Project and the report's author, explained some states' Raise the Age reforms haven't addressed other pathways into adult court, such as judicial transfer or automatic transfer, laws that allow youths to be charged as adults for more serious offenses regardless of their age, and are disproportionately applied to Black and brown youths.
"We have pathways that allow very young children, and in some states, that's under the age of ten, that still can be treated as adults," Mistrett pointed out. "Those are for more serious crimes, generally speaking, but that should not be allowed. The United States is an outlier in that."
She added mounting evidence suggests states should work to close expensive and largely ineffective detention centers and redirect resources toward a continuum of community care that allows the vast majority of youths to remain in their communities with strong supports.
get more stories like this via email
Health and Wellness
LEWISBURG, W.Va. -- Political canvassers and organizers in the state are expecting they will continue to struggle with challenges to traditional …
CHEYENNE, Wyo. -- A federal court agreed with conservationists this week, ordering winter feeding of elk on the Bridger-Teton National Forest …
FARGO, N.D. -- In the near future, North Dakota is poised to help resettle 49 Afghan evacuees who fled their home country after the U.S. military …
MCCALL, Idaho -- After the rejection of a developer's proposed land swap near Payette Lake, a coalition of groups wants the state to do the opposite…
Health and Wellness
DENVER -- Colorado's ability to respond to COVID-19 was blunted by decades of disinvestment in critical public services, according to a new report…
GERING, Neb. -- With school back in session, many Nebraska students will be fueled by fresh beef, fruits and vegetables sourced from local farms…
By Abaki Beck for Yes!Media.Broadcast version by Mike Moen for Minnesota News Connection reporting for the YES! Media-Public News Service …
ANNAPOLIS, Md. - Farm bureaus and agricultural leaders of Chesapeake Bay watershed states are pushing the U.S. Department of Agriculture to fund a …