Nearly a quarter-million children were incarcerated in the U.S. in 2019, about five times more than annual point-in-time counts, according to a new report.
Dona Playton, associate law professor at the University of Wyoming, said locking kids up actually increases the chance they will commit additional crimes. They miss time at school and fall behind, and are much more likely to end up in the school-to-prison pipeline.
"They lose connections within their community, within their peer groups," Playton explained. "It negatively impacts their families. It is so expensive, in the long run, compared to the cost of prevention."
She said programs and treatment to address family trauma and other root causes of misbehavior are much more effective at reducing recidivism. The report comes after Wyoming lawmakers recently passed House Bill 37, an effort to collect data on juveniles in the criminal justice system. Policymakers hope to get a better picture of why Wyoming has long had one of the highest child incarceration rates in the nation.
The Sentencing Project study found rates of incarceration are much higher in low-income neighborhoods and communities of color, where there is a higher police presence.
Josh Rovner, senior advocacy associate for The Sentencing Project and the report's author, said it has created troubling racial disparities.
"Overall, one out of every four kids who are sent to court are detained at the outset," Rovner reported. "Now, for white youths, that is one out of every five. For Black and Latino youths, closer to 30%. And that is not connected to the seriousness of the offense."
Incarcerated children are at a higher risk of being victims of violence or sexual abuse while they are in detention, and are less likely to graduate from high school and find employment later in life.
Playton argued "scared straight" tactics, the notion that children who experience jail will get their act together, are misguided because kids are not just little adults.
"Children's brains are not fully developed, and so they don't make the best decisions," Playton emphasized. "When we treat them with punishment instead of rehabilitation or treatment, it doesn't account for the collateral consequences to them and to their family."
get more stories like this via email
Nearly 2,000 South Dakota juveniles were successfully diverted from the state's court system this year, according to a new report.
A 2024 law has added fiscal incentive for counties to continue these diversion efforts.
When low-risk youth are diverted from the court system, they are 45% less likely to reoffend, according to the Annie E. Casey Foundation.
Diversion can take many forms, from mural-painting to skateboarding programs.
State's Attorney Lara Roetzel in Pennington County, where diversion programs have been used for about 25 years, said they can help unveil the root cause of a child's misbehavior.
"Diversion gives you a chance to really get to know that young person, and get them the help that they need," said Roetzel, "because it's not always obvious."
For example, she said, a child caught stealing may be doing so to support a drug habit - and would be best served through addiction counseling.
The Department of Social Services has also expanded community-based treatment options for youth, including functional family therapy and aggression replacement therapy, according to a draft 2024 report from the state's Juvenile Justice Oversight Council.
When a child avoids court or incarceration, the state saves money - so the state compensates counties for the cost per child of successful diversions.
South Dakota Senate Bill 47, passed this year, increased the amount paid from $250 to $750 per child. Roetzel said that allows the diversion programming to continue.
"It meant that I just wrote a check this week," said Roetzel, "that will allow me to pay for classes for almost all of the young people that will go through my juvenile diversion programs next year."
This is particularly helpful, she said, because otherwise the outstanding costs land on parents - who often can't afford to pay them.
get more stories like this via email
When a 6-year-old girl in Florida had a temper tantrum in class, it seemed like a typical childhood moment.
But instead of calming the situation, a school resource officer placed her in a squad car, fingerprinted her and took a mug shot, which left lasting emotional scars.
Delvin Davis, senior policy analyst at the Southern Poverty Law Center, said the case highlights a troubling ongoing concern: disparities in how discipline is enforced, particularly for Black and brown children. This case and others are highlighted in his report, "Only Young Once: The Systemic Harm of Florida's School-to-Prison Pipeline and Youth Legal System."
"As you can imagine, it was a very traumatic experience for her," Davis explained. "She's older now, but still it has lingering on ongoing effects for her -- mentally and how she does well in school and how she interacts with other people, things like that -- and how she interacts with authority figures as well."
Following the case, in 2021, the Florida Legislature passed the "Kaia Rolle Act," which prohibits the arrest of children under age 7, except in cases involving a forcible felony. However, children as young as 7 can still be arrested and prosecuted in the state.
Davis' report examined how school discipline policies, combined with a significant increase in law enforcement presence in schools, have exacerbated the problem, particularly in the aftermath of the Marjory Stoneman Douglas school shooting. Davis noted it led to a sharp rise in school-based policing.
"Once you expel or suspend a kid from school, there's a higher correlation for dropout rates," Davis pointed out. "And pretty much the first step into the school to prison pipeline is a downward spiral, where you're more likely to see that kid detained later on, arrested later on and further on into the penal system."
At the heart of Davis's findings is a call for systemic change to ensure schools are places of support and growth, not gateways to the juvenile justice system. The report also pointed to solutions, emphasizing community-based programs as more effective alternatives to punitive discipline.
get more stories like this via email
The holiday season is a difficult time of year for families with children in Washington's youth detention centers. Families have limited access to children in prisons.
Rashida Robbins has a child in Green Hill School, a 180-bed facility in Chehalis. She said families were invited to holiday dinners in early December but noted it was long before Christmas and on that day, she said, there will be a hole in her home that cannot be filled.
"It's pretty tough, and the lack of access to him during these times makes it even tougher," Robbins explained. "The thought of him just sitting in a locked room makes it unbearable as a parent. It's really rough."
Gov. Jay Inslee has announced a proposal for a new youth facility to address overcrowding, specifically at Green Hill. Organizations, including Kids Are Kids and TeamChild, have criticized the plan, saying it does not address the current concerns at Green Hill.
Stacy Stanaway said unaddressed issues have been the case for her son, who suffered from behavioral challenges before he was sent to Green Hill. She added a disciplinary action meant she was not able to visit for the family holiday earlier in the month.
"We can't just isolate people from their family, from their community and expect things to just go away," Stanaway argued. "And so, with my son the holidays especially are really, really difficult for us because he has younger siblings, he has older siblings."
A spokesperson for Green Hill said because the holiday event involved a high number of visitors, the behavior expectations leading up to the event were "no physical aggression and drug use 30 days in advance" for safety reasons.
Stanaway acknowledged much of the healing for her boy will have to happen after he comes back from the youth facility.
"It's going to be a phase and a period of time that's going to take years, in reality, of recovery for my child," Stanaway stressed. "I feel that time is paused right now."
Robbins added sometimes, it feels like kids are never meant to get out of a facility like Green Hill. She implores state leaders to do something.
"I would challenge the people that have the power to make changes to do so and be on the right side of history," Robbins concluded.
get more stories like this via email