Lawsuit Targets VT’s Medical Aid-in- Dying Law's Residency Rule
Thursday, September 1, 2022
A nonprofit group is suing the state of Vermont on behalf of a New York and Vermont doctor and a terminally ill woman.
At issue is Vermont's medical aid-in-dying law, which stipulates only residents of Vermont are eligible for the services the law allows.
In 2018, a medical aid-in-dying law failed in New York's Legislature.
Dr. Diana Barnard, a hospice and palliative-care doctor in Vermont and a plaintiff in the case, said she has New York patients who have asked about medical aid-in-dying as an option to end their suffering. Although she has to provide them with different treatment than her Vermont patients, she has heard some common questions about access.
"Pretty much all my patients say the same things," Barnard explained. "Which is, 'Why can't I have access to this, if it feels right for me. It's my life, it's my death, it's my suffering. Nobody else can understand. Why are people limiting my options?' "
She hopes the lawsuit is a catalyst for this becoming a more widely recognized tool to ease the suffering of terminal patients. One thing she is adamant about is listening to patients and understanding what type of end-of-life care is best for them. The lawsuit was filed by the group Compassion & Choices and the case is in the U.S. District Court in Vermont.
Lynda Bluestein, a Connecticut resident and plaintiff in the lawsuit, was diagnosed with Stage Three fallopian-tube cancer, her third diagnosis in three years. A bill to create a medical aid-in-dying law failed in the Connecticut Legislature.
Bluestein feels people with terminal illnesses should have the right to end their suffering on their terms, no matter where they live.
"I can't hold my breath for Connecticut, this place that I love, my home," Bluestein asserted. "This is where I get all of my care, I have my network of friends, my support system. They're all here. People say, 'Why don't you just move to Vermont and drop the lawsuit?' Well, just moving isn't just moving for anybody."
Should it be decided against her, Bluestein would have to move to Vermont and establish residency.
Washington, D.C., and 10 states have medical aid-in-dying laws with residency requirements. Oregon's requirement was eliminated in March, after a legal challenge.
get more stories like this via email
Holiday shoppers this week have no shortage of options with Small Business Saturday being observed on Nov. 26. Sandwiched between Black Friday and …
By Lucia Walinchus for Eye on Ohio.Broadcast version by Nadia Ramlagan for Ohio News Connection Collaboration reporting for the Ohio Center for Invest…
While many Iowa families gather through this weekend to celebrate Thanksgiving in traditional ways with food and family, thousands of people take to …
Members of a Detroit-area community are intervening in an Environmental Protection Agency lawsuit against a DTE Energy subsidiary charged with dumping…
Health and Wellness
A bill headed to President Joe Biden's desk addresses a long-standing problem for domestic violence survivors, ending their ties to their abusers' …
Oregon is home to a plethora of rivers, but those waterways are not always accessible to every community. A new video series highlights how …
California is number one in the country for dollars spent on camping, hiking, climbing, and biking, according to the latest federal data. The most …
As holiday shopping kicks into high gear, security experts are offering tips for avoiding efforts by scammers to separate people from their hard-…