Amicus Briefs Filed in CA Elder Abuse, Arbitration Case
Thursday, June 8, 2023
This week, four advocacy groups have filed an amicus brief in a case before the California Supreme Court involving allegations of elder abuse and the use of arbitration.
A skilled nursing facility, Country Oaks in Pomona, is trying to compel arbitration in a case where the patient, Charles Logan, gave his nephew power to sign healthcare documents but did not give him power of attorney - and later Logan sued Country Oaks, alleging negligence.
An appellate court decided the nephew had no legal standing to sign the mediation agreement as part of the intake forms.
Jessica Pezley, senior staff attorney with the advocacy group Compassion & Choices, contended the California Supreme Court should uphold that prior decision.
"The healthcare decisions law only concerns healthcare decisions," said Pezley. "It does not concern decisions affecting future legal rights. And so, when somebody signs an advance directive, nowhere in their mind, are they thinking they might be waiving their constitutional right to a jury trial."
Country Oaks argues the mediation agreement should remain in force.
Logan has since passed away. Federal policy under the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services states that mediation agreements are strictly optional and cannot be required for admission to a facility.
Pezley said corporate mediation is often weighted in favor of the defendant.
"By compelling arbitration, Logan would not have had his constitutional right to have a trial by jury," said Pezley. "Instead, he would go in front of an arbitrator, which tend to be in favor of corporations - just because corporations are the ones who are tending to use arbitration on a repeat basis."
Logan's estate is now pursuing the case. The California Supreme Court has not yet announced a hearing date.
get more stories like this via email
A California group formed after the firestorm that leveled the town of Paradise is stepping up to help Maui recover from its own disaster last month…
Skills for reducing violence are becoming essential in schools. At the beginning of the school year, students at a Washington state high school …
The age-old theory that opposites attract has been debunked. According to analysis of more than 130 traits in a study that included millions of …
A new report questions New York City Mayor Eric Adams' latest budget proposal for dealing with the city's influx of over 110,000 migrants. The cost …
A federal judge has blocked a 2022 Arizona law that voting-rights advocates say would have made it harder for some Native Americans to vote. House …
Thousands of U.S. auto workers remain on strike, and the walkout is being felt in Minnesota. A rally was scheduled this morning in the Twin Cities …
If states like Minnesota are going to meet their climate goals, experts say younger workers will need to step into the roles to make it happen - like …
Health and Wellness
In rural Arkansas, access to healthcare can be a distant dream - literally - as almost 60 counties in the state do not have enough providers to serve …