This month, an Arizona grand jury indicted two out-of-state residents for cheating the state's Empowerment Scholarship Account program out of more than $110,000. Now, critics of the program believe Arizona Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Horne's latest decision could open the door to similar problems.

The Republican-backed program has grown in popularity, leading to a backlog of reimbursement requests. Horne recently decided to approve all requests of less than $2,000.

Beth Lewis, director of Save Our Schools Arizona, said accurately reviewing 85,000 transactions will be a challenge.

"My skepticism is rooted in the history of the program under Horne the last couple of years," Lewis explained. "I don't think anybody really has hope that there will be actual accountability but what's even worse is this sets a really dangerous precedent going forward."

Lewis acknowledged many Arizona families use the program as intended but it is not guaranteed. The Department of Education said its new auditing system will work to detect suspicious activity in accounts. Horne argued approving tens of thousands of payments will significantly diminish the backlog of requests.

Lewis pointed out this year's state budget stripped funding from public schools and higher education and fully funded the voucher program. She added Gov. Katie Hobbs and Democrats were unable to work with the Republican-led majority on the issue of adequately funding public schools and hopes more can be done next year.

"I worry that we're going to see a lot more school closures and staff layoffs, teacher layoffs and other funding cuts this year," Lewis stressed. "I know that Arizona voters support our schools and I really hope that we can start to see maybe a space of a little bit more bipartisanship, around Prop 123, for example."

Funding for Proposition 123 comes from the State Land Trust, which needs voters' approval to be directed to K-12 education.

Hobbs has announced a Proposition 123 renewal plan to increase teacher compensation and improve school safety. While it has garnered some bipartisan support, policymakers have not reached a consensus on all the details. Funding is set to expire in July 2025.


get more stories like this via email

Utah still ranks as one of the best states for children's overall well-being, according to a new national report but advocates are stressing the need for more investments in positive youth engagement and education.

Utah ranked fourth in this year's Kids Count Data Book, which looked at 16 key indicators to holistically assess how children are doing.

Martín Muñoz, Kids Count director at Voices for Utah Children, said despite Utah's strong standing and promising trends, the state should not become complacent. He noted many families are still struggling and said uncertainty at the national level is being felt locally.

"We hear about it almost daily -- the housing crisis, the cost of living -- Utah is struggling," Muñoz observed. "One in four Utah children live in a household with a high housing cost burden in 2023."

Muñoz pointed out it means about 234,000 Utah households are spending more than 30% of their income on housing. He contended implementing what he called "trickle down economic" policies like the Child Tax Credit, which offers families up to $2,000 for every eligible child, could help. But as the budget reconciliation package makes its way through Congress, lawmakers could impose new regulations on who is eligible.

Some of the Beehive State's bright spots include seeing fewer children living in poverty as well as fewer children without health insurance. Muñoz emphasized investments made now to provide Utah families with economic opportunities and children with quality education and health care will pay off years down the road.

"We have resources that can provide and implement policies that do better for all kids and families," Muñoz asserted. "It is really being smart about our investments."

The annual report found education in Utah is still a glaring issue, as 64% of Utah fourth graders are not proficient in reading and 65% of eighth graders are not proficient in math.

Leslie Boissiere, vice president of external affairs for the Annie E. Casey Foundation, said it is why states need to invest in areas like tutoring, while looking at effective curriculum strategies to turn the numbers around.

"Investing in thriving kids is essential to investing in communities, investing in our nation and investing in a strong economy 'cause today's kids are tomorrow's workforce," Boissiere stressed.

Tennessee ranks in the middle among states for the well-being of its children, at 37th overall in the new Kids Count Data Book from the Annie E. Casey Foundation.

The annual report ranks states on the overall condition of children in four areas: economic well-being, education, health, and community and family.

Grace Baron, director of external relations for The Sycamore Institute, a nonpartisan public policy research center, said the data book show Tennessee students have made gains since the pandemic, particularly compared with students across the nation. She pointed out Tennessee has significantly improved reading and math proficiency.

"Tennessee's overall education ranking was 14th, which is the highest the state has ever achieved in rankings regarding fourth grade education and eighth grade math proficiency on national assessments, and Tennessee tied for the number two spot for on-time high school graduation," Baron outlined. "That means we're second out of all 50 states."

This year's report ranked Tennessee 35th in economic well-being. The state did see improvements in family and community, and the number of children living in high-poverty areas and children in single-parent families decreased.

Baron emphasized Tennessee's rankings slipped for several key health measures reaching a 14-year low. Tennessee is 41st place for child health, with mental health a key concern. She added recent data from her group showed Tennessee's youths are faring better in their mental health than a lot of other states.

"Tennessee had the sixth-lowest prevalence of depression and anxiety among youths in the country," Baron underscored. "Youth Mental Health is a growing concern as mental health indicators have been trending in the wrong direction for a while now, both in Tennessee and nationally."

Baron added Sycamore's work led to a new state law aimed at improving coordination among nine agencies overseeing children's mental health to boost outcomes for Tennessee kids.

Leslie Boissiere, vice president of external affairs for the Annie E. Casey Foundation, said federal lawmakers are debating the future scope of safety net programs such as Medicaid and SNAP, with those decisions likely to affect state budgets. Boissiere stressed she hopes the unbiased data in this report gets a strong look ahead of any final moves.

"I think it's critically important that policymakers look at the data on food security in their community, that they look at the data on access to health care, that they look at what's been effective in driving child well-being," Boissiere urged.

Boissiere highlighted the importance of recognizing ongoing racial disparities in child well-being, noting Native American children fall below the national average on 15 of 16 indicators, while Black children lag on 8 of the 16 measures, with similar results for Latino children.

Vermont ranks high in overall child well-being, with fewer children living in poverty, according to a new report.

Released today, the 2025 Kids Count Data Book from the Annie E. Casey Foundation shows 9% of children live in families below the federal poverty level, as more parents gain secure employment.

Sarah Teel, research director with Voices for Vermont's Children, credited state investments in education and health care and an expanded Child Tax Credit, which put more cash in parents' pockets.

"That approach has worked, and it has made a difference, and it is the reason why we've seen the positive outcomes we have," said Teel, "and so protecting that should be one of our top priorities."

Teel said expansion of Green Mountain Care and the Children's Health Insurance Program has helped ensure nearly all kids in Vermont have health insurance.

She said it's important that state lawmakers keep listening to families and stick with proven, research-backed policy choices.

Post-pandemic learning loss continues to plague educational outcomes in the state.

Nearly 70% of fourth graders lack proficiency in reading and more than 70% of eighth graders lack proficiency in math.

Leslie Boissiere, vice president of external affairs with the Annie E. Casey Foundation, said prioritizing intervention strategies, to ensure more kids are in school and graduating on time, will ultimately help both families and the state's economy.

"With things like internships and apprenticeships, stronger - and in some cases - alternative education," said Boissiere, "so that they have an opportunity to thrive, and to move forward from education and into the workforce."

Federal lawmakers are considering significant cuts to public safety net programs like Medicaid and SNAP.

Boissiere said she hopes they'll consider the data on food security, health care, and other indicators driving child well-being before making any moves.