Analysis: Business Property-Tax Cut Wouldn’t Bring Jobs
Monday, January 14, 2019
CHARLESTON, W.Va. – The governor and legislative leaders again are considering repealing the personal property tax for businesses.
But according to the West Virginia Center on Budget and Policy, it's unlikely to bring job growth.
Last year, lawmakers looked at ending that tax on inventory, machinery and equipment.
Sean O'Leary, a senior policy analyst the center, says most states tax either inventory, or machinery and equipment, or both.
He says comparisons have found no real connection to growth no matter what states do.
"Since the end of the recession, there's no real clear link between states that have this tax, states that don't have this tax, and growth rates,” he points out. “And states that have neither of the taxes have actually grown less than the states that have both."
Leaders at the Legislature say repealing the tax would get more businesses to locate in the state.
But O'Leary says the tax is just a "fraction of a fraction" of a company's costs – not nearly enough to change anyone's mind.
He says West Virginia is "fairly middle of the road" in the way it structures these taxes.
The state has a very low property tax rate overall.
O'Leary says part of that is because it applies the tax to a broad range of things.
He says states that do not tax inventory, machinery or equipment have to make up the income by raising other kinds of property taxes.
"So their land and buildings are getting taxed at a much higher rate than they are in West Virginia,” he explains. “So the savings that they would have doesn't really add up to anything."
Supporters say eliminating the tax would cost the state about $140 million a year, once it's fully in place.
O'Leary says the real total price tag would be more than $300 million a year, with much of the cost landing first on county school systems.
He notes the state would have to reimburse the schools for the lost revenue, and that strong public education is much more likely to boost employment.
get more stories like this via email
ARLINGTON, Va. -- As a Northern Virginia school system transitions away from using police officers in schools, a new report suggests COVID stimulus …
DES MOINES, Iowa -- In five weeks, voters in many Iowa cities will cast their ballots for local elections, and the Secretary of State's office is …
AURORA, Colo. -- School districts across Colorado had to get creative to ensure families could access critical meals during pandemic-related closures…
SUPERIOR, Wis. -- Legal proceedings continue involving a proposed natural-gas plant for northwestern Wisconsin. The plans have been approved by state …
PORTLAND, Ore. -- Draft rules are out for a program designed to confront climate change in Oregon, but organizations say it does not go far enough to …
Health and Wellness
ALBUQUERQUE, N.M. -- A veterinary drug doctors call unsafe for treating COVID-19 has caused the deaths of two people in New Mexico, according to the …
RALEIGH, N.C. -- North Carolina Gov. Roy Cooper signed sweeping criminal-justice reform into law this month that is meant to hold police more …
Health and Wellness
BALTIMORE -- Spurred on by COVID challenges, a grant from the Maryland Developmental Disabilities Council to two human services providers is …