Report Warns of False Narratives Surrounding Youth Crime
Tuesday, June 28, 2022
New research found reports of skyrocketing youth crime are not only unfounded, but are fueling calls for stricter punishments.
Data from the Sentencing Project showed the share of crimes in the U.S. committed by young people fell by more than half in the past two decades. It also decreased in all major types of offenses in 2020.
Richard Mendel, senior research fellow for The Sentencing Project and the report's author, said there has been alarming news coverage and rhetoric from politicians regarding the false crime wave, and it is important for states to continue working to divert kids from the justice system rather than returning to more tough-on-crime policies.
"This is not a moment to be panicking about youth crime," Mendel asserted. "Especially if that panic is going to lead us to embrace solutions that we know that the evidence shows do not work."
According to the report, juvenile detention and transfers to adult court can worsen youth outcomes. Instead, Mendel encouraged reforms to help drive young people away from delinquency, including reducing reliance on youth confinement and making stronger investments in social and mental-health supports in schools and communities.
Jason Smith, executive director of the Michigan Center for Youth Justice, said Michigan has made progress in recent years such as raising the age of criminal responsibility, and he contended it is important nationally not to slip back into a tough-on-crime way of thinking. He hopes the state continues to expand alternatives to the justice system.
"How can we expand diversion to provide resources and support and treatment to young people who may have needs but may not necessarily require court supervision to address those needs or involvement in the legal system?" Smith questioned.
Smith added there is still room for Michigan to grow on juvenile justice policies. He noted there is a big issue of youth and families burdened by significant debt to pay off court fees and fines, which he argued needs to change.
"That is harmful to the family, but also creates a negative relationship between them and the justice professionals that they engage with," Smith observed. "And hurts that collaboration that really is beneficial to the juvenile-justice system, collaborating with families and parents in a way that we don't see in the adult system as much."
get more stories like this via email
The Iowa League of Women Voters plans to ask the Iowa Legislature to rethink the voting restrictions put in place prior to last month's midterm electi…
Agriculture groups and government agencies aren't slowing down in trying to convince farmers to use more sustainable practices such as cover crops…
Winter is here, leaving many older South Dakotans vulnerable to social isolation. But a growing body of research, as well as opportunities, shows …
By Jala Forest / Broadcast version by Nadia Ramlagan Reporting for the Kent State-Ohio News Connection Collaboration Nearly 40% of college students a…
The Biden administration has proposed a rule to limit methane flaring from oil and gas development on public lands. The rule would impose royalty …
The flu, COVID and RSV are rapidly spreading in Kentucky, and health experts say that's a problem for hospitals, schools and the state's vulnerable …
As its 125th anniversary nears, the Connecticut Audubon Society has released a report detailing the effectiveness of conservation efforts in the …
2022 was a banner year for women elected as governor. Nearly one-third of America's governors will be women next year, which is a record. Iowa …