Separating high school students from their cellphones might be seen as a daunting task but one California school said having students stash them during the school day has brought some surprising results.

Administrators at High Tech High in San Diego said fostering a phone-free school environment led to positive change. Starting this school year, High Tech High required students to relinquish their phones at the beginning of the day.

Colleen Glass, compliance officer for the school, said tracking student perceptions and observing the impact of cellphones on the learning culture provides a compelling case study.

"Where before, they were sitting in those spaces and kind of 'heads down' into their technology, they're now sitting in those spaces and having conversations," Glass explained. "There's a lot more engagement and conversation in class, because students are talking to each other and they're not listening to their AirPods."

Across the country, more than three-quarters of K-12 public schools prohibit nonacademic cellphone use, according to a report from the 2021-2022 school year. But only 43% of public high schools have such a rule and it is often not enforced.

Doug Keller, partnerships lead for the nonprofit Youth Truth, said it has been tracking students' experiences over the past decade in such areas as engagement, relationships, culture, academic challenges and their overall sense of belonging. He noted once the phones were gone from classes, the majority of students showed improvement in several areas.

"When they implemented the policy, we saw a sharp jump upward," Keller reported. "We saw growth, students feeling a stronger sense of belonging at their school because of this new policy, after seeing a decline that matched the decline that we have anecdotally seen elsewhere."

Keller added Youth Truth surveyed students to measure the "intersection of student voice, school improvement and key indicators of the student experience." It also includes areas like peer collaboration and relationships with their teachers. He emphasized they will continue the study in future years.

Chronic absenteeism rates in Michigan schools have significantly declined, yet researchers warn the state's rate overall remains alarmingly high.

"Chronic absenteeism" is when a student misses at least 10% of the school year.

Michigan's rate dropped from nearly 39% to slightly more than 30% in the 2022-23 school year, but it's still higher than the 20% recorded in 2018. Climate change and extreme weather are now seen as factors that fuel absenteeism.

Veteran first-grade teacher Janice Rackozy from Hamtramck shares how her students face challenges during bad weather.

"Lot of the kids, if it's too cold, they won't come to school. If it's too hot, they call weather days. So, it interrupts the learning," she said. "One good thing out of it, we began to go online and the kids got used to going online because of COVID."

However, learning gaps because of the pandemic haven't closed.

Rackozy said her district has been proactive in making sure school buildings are updated and well insulated so students feel comfortable and safe when at school.

Many educators credit Michigan's Top 10 Strategic Education Plan, at least in part, for the decline in school absenteeism. The plan details key goals and strategies for better educational outcomes throughout the state, including support for struggling schools and promoting safe and healthy school environments.

Frank Donner, an elementary teacher in Detroit, said he tells parents at the beginning of the school year that if they do nothing else, just make sure their child comes to class.

"If they're here, we're going to work with them, and we can do a lot, and they will do a lot," he said. "But for every day that the student's missing, they're missing instruction, and it's not just that individual student that's missing out. It's also disrupting then the learning and routines and procedures for the rest of the class."

Donner said chronic school absenteeism affects students and staff equally, and that it's as big an issue in rural communities as it is in big cities or suburbs.


get more stories like this via email

The start of a new year of school in Minnesota has a new twist: intense focus from national media and voters across the U.S.

With Gov. Tim Walz running for vice president, many are trying to measure his impact from the classroom to policy decisions. On the campaign trail, Gov. Walz has talked about his career as a public schoolteacher. On the governing side, his push to help adopt free school meals for all students has drawn attention.

Bob Ihrig, a retired social studies teacher from Mankato, is among some of Walz' former colleagues from Mankato West High School speaking out. He said Walz exceeded their expectations when they hired him.

"He's just an outstanding role model for any future teacher," Ihrig contended. "There's a lot of hope and inspiration with Tim Walz."

Ihrig suggested it could help make the profession appealing to younger generations amid teacher shortages. In politics, Walz maintains strong support from unions, including the American Federation of Teachers, for actions like a taking a hard stance against private school vouchers. His opponents argued he kept schools closed for too long during the pandemic, subsequently hurting student test scores.

Walz' supporters countered he took proper steps to keep everyone safe and his administration is committed to reducing learning gaps.

Aaron Miller, a current social studies teacher at Mankato West High School, said student performance is a complex issue, along with education funding. Under Walz, public schools have received a big boost but many districts still have tight budgets. Miller pointed out it could be a lot worse.

"That money that was thrown out really just kind of helped us kind of catch up a little bit," Miller explained. "Public school funding is a hornet's nest of people demanding certain things. And there are a lot of things to consider when you're going into it; property taxes."

Miller feels the perception of public schools is too steeped in "culture war" issues often pushed by conservative groups. While he does not agree with every policy move Walz has made, Miller stressed a renewed focus on the mission aligned with being a teacher should stay in the limelight much longer.

"We need our administrations, we need our state Department of Education, to do some things to help re-instill that sense of support and respect," Miller emphasized.

Classroom supplies are taking a toll on teachers in North Carolina.

A new survey showed despite earning around 5% less than they did a decade ago, North Carolina teachers are spending the fourth-highest amount in the country on school supplies.

Tamika Walker Kelly, president of the North Carolina Association of Educators, said teachers are dipping into their own pockets due to insufficient state funding for instructional materials.

"Educators in North Carolina are spending about $1,300 of their own money, $400 more than the national average," Walker Kelly pointed out. "We continue to see that rise amongst our educators here in the state. "

She noted the association is urging state legislators to invest in school supplies and reinstate the state's Tax Holiday to help teachers and parents save money. There have also been calls from Attorney General and Democratic nominee for governor Josh Stein to introduce a plan to reduce back-to-school costs.

Walker Kelly emphasized the rising expenses are coupled with low teacher salaries. North Carolina, currently ranked 38th in average teacher pay, is projected to drop to 41st by the 2024-25 school year, according to the National Education Association.

She contended financial pressures have led to staffing shortages, which ultimately affect students' learning experiences.

"We know that our state Legislature could make that investment," Walker Kelly asserted. "That's why we are continuing to advocate for that because we see record numbers of educators flee to South Carolina and to Virginia and to Georgia because of that $10,000 pay difference."

She also highlighted the issue of salary stagnation for veteran educators with 15 or more years of experience. The top salary on North Carolina's teacher pay scale is just over $61,000, which teachers reach after 25 years. Between years 15 and 24, there is no growth in pay, leaving veteran teachers without raises for nearly a decade.