Opposition Grows to Mandatory E-Verify Legislation
Thursday, July 14, 2011
SACRAMENTO, Calif. - As Congress considers legislation that would require all employers to verify their employees' social security numbers, critics of mandatory E-Verify say the legislation is a guaranteed failure when it comes to California's agriculture industry.
A new report from the immigration reform organization America's Voice finds that the legislation being sponsored by a number of California's Republican Congressional representatives is riddled with problems. The report highlights a range of studies, including one from Bloomberg, that have found mandatory E-Verify would cost small businesses $2.6 billion to implement.
America's Voice Executive Director Frank Sharry points to another implication: The loss of immigrant labor would leave food rotting in the fields in California.
"Seventy to 80 percent of the workers in agriculture in California are here without papers. And the three to four jobs that are created for each farmworker - packing, transportation, marketing and sales - would also be lost."
The report also finds mandatory E-Verify would not even work as intended, citing research that shows the current version of the database successfully identifies undocumented workers less than half of the time.
Eric Larson, executive director of the San Diego County Farm Bureau, says there is already a shortage of farmworkers in California. He is convinced that if the legislation is passed, many farms will shut down.
"What we need is a program put in place first, so that we have this steady supply of workers that can withstand the E-Verify scrutiny. If we do the E-Verify first, all we will do is deplete the force of workers."
Larson says the Farm Bureau would welcome E-Verify, but only after the country has a guest worker program in place or recognizes workers who are on the pathway to permanent residency or citizenship.
The America's Voice report is at www.americasvoiceonline.org.
get more stories like this via email
Health and Wellness
California's medical aid-in-dying law is back in court. Three patients with disabilities and two doctors are asking to intervene in a lawsuit …
A new federal jobs program aims to mobilize tens of thousands of young Americans to address the growing threats of climate change. The American …
Little Priest Tribal College in Winnebago says its student body and campus are growing - and so are its options for people to study in STEM fields…
Health and Wellness
By Nathalia Teixeira for Kent State News Lab.Broadcast version by Nadia Ramlagan reporting for the Kent State-Ohio News Connection Collaboration…
Maine's new Office of Affordable Health Care holds its first public hearing this week, and people are being strongly encouraged to participate…
The number of children locked behind bars in Alabama has declined, but their advocates said more needs to be done to create alternatives to …
This coming Saturday, North Dakotans will get a chance to see how election workers go to great lengths to ensure a safe and secure voting process…
Scientists at Purdue University have been experimenting to create adhesives designed to be easier on the environment. So many products from …