IA Expert: SCOTUS Election Case Should Be on Public's Radar
Wednesday, July 27, 2022
Legal analysts and voting-rights advocates are looking ahead to this fall, when the U.S. Supreme Court hears arguments on a case about state legislatures and election oversight. An Iowa expert sees a mixed outlook.
The case stems from a redistricting dispute in North Carolina and floats what is known as the Independent State Legislature Theory.
Republicans who support it feel a clause in the U.S. Constitution gives legislatures broad powers over federal elections without having to abide by restrictions from state-level courts.
Derek Muller, professor of law at the University of Iowa, said the case should be on the public's radar in the event the court agrees with the theory.
"There is the potential, then, if state legislatures say, 'Oh, we can get more creative, or we can push the boundaries more,' " Muller cautioned. "That is another thing to think about."
But even with a favorable decision, he pointed out a lot would depend on how narrow the court's opinion would be.
Muller added Congress has a say, and existing federal backstops already cover other elements of voting, including mail-in ballots and registration. Pro-democracy groups worry a broad opinion could lead to voter suppression and more efforts to overturn results.
Last year, Iowa Republicans pushed to enact several voting restrictions. The North Carolina case deals with gerrymandered maps, but Muller does not see a potential outcome motivating lawmakers here to make big moves.
Iowa is known for its independent process, and he acknowledged the legislature has largely yielded to it.
"It's chosen to defer to what the agency has done," Muller stated. "I think it's a testament to how the Legislature has trusted what's been happening in that process."
Muller stressed it is important to remember the theory in question only deals with federal election oversight. Depending on the outcome of the case, he predicted a big question for legislatures will be if they want to enact separate voting rules for different levels of government.
get more stories like this via email
Health and Wellness
A bill moving through the Kentucky Legislature would make fluoride treatment in drinking water optional for local municipalities. House Bill 141 …
New York state lawmakers have appointed members to the Community Commission on Reparations Remedies, created through legislation Gov. Kathy Hochul …
A new report argued many charitable foundations need to examine the origin of their wealth and repair harms done. The National Committee for …
A proposed urban reforestation program in Massachusetts aims to help cities mitigate the effects of climate change. Legislation would create a state …
A Wyoming nonprofit is helping single mothers climb out of poverty by connecting them with the training and support they need to step into and succeed…
Even though March is barely underway, parents of Wisconsin kids are being encouraged to plan for summer reading activities - especially if their …
A law aimed at immigrants crossing the border in Texas will not take effect tomorrow, after a federal judge halted enforcement until a court battle …
Minnesota already has a law calling for 100% carbon-free electricity by 2040. Now, there's a similar plan for transportation, and a legislative …